Congratulations, Florida, on a third men’s national title. Your six-game run to the championship not only included multiple stirring comebacks from second-half deficits, it also lifted you into the top 10 for tournament wins since the field expanded to 64 teams in 1985.

Well done, Gators. Tough luck, former top-10 member Michigan.

Expanding the field 40 years ago did away with byes, giving us a trusty measuring stick when teams accumulate tournament victories over the years. Yes, the NCAA muddied that up a bit by expanding past 64 teams starting in 2001, but we can adjust with a well-placed asterisk here and there.

Top 25 for NCAA men’s tournament wins, 1985-2025

                          Wins
1.   Duke                 109    
2.   North Carolina        99* 2025 
3.   Kansas                94
4.   Kentucky              86
5.   UConn                 68
6.   Michigan State        66
7.   Arizona               60
8.   Syracuse              57* 2018
9.   UCLA                  56* 2021
10.  Florida               54 (Congrats!)
11.  Michigan              53* 2016
12.  Louisville            49
13.  Villanova             47
     Gonzaga               47
15.  Purdue                42
16.  Arkansas              40
17.  Maryland              37
     Oklahoma              37
     Wisconsin             37
     Indiana               37* 2022
21.  Ohio State            35
22.  Illinois              34
     Texas                 34
24.  Georgetown            33
25.  Xavier                31* 2025

* Round of 68 victory

In other news I think we can all agree that the big story coming out of the 2025 bracket is Kansas and its shocking performance against seed expectation in years when it does not win it all.

First, some background….

On the evening of March 15, 2011, Alex Garcia-Mendoza drained a three for Little Rock with 18:47 remaining in the first half of the Trojans’ First Four game against UNC Asheville in Dayton. It was the first three-pointer in the opening game of the 2011 NCAA tournament.

Garcia-Mendoza’s trey marks a convenient boundary line. The field had just expanded to 68 teams that year. As of this writing we are three games shy of having played 15 full brackets in this current configuration.

In the 68-team era NCAA tournament teams have made nearly 13,000 threes on about 38,000 attempts. The 15-tournament figure for accuracy from behind the arc thus stands at 33.6 percent, but keep in mind the line was moved back prior to the tipoff of the 2021 bracket. A more accurate rendering of March Madness accuracy might note instead that with the current line teams are 4,816-of-14,557 (33.1 percent) across the last five tournaments.

Recurring 2020s-era exposés on bad three-point shooting in the tournament and on any potential culpability of the ball itself are therefore eminently understandable if not historically predetermined. Such pieces give voice to the disillusion and bafflement of we oldsters who proudly carry sentient memories of the 2010s.

We old-timers recall a pre-pandemic idyll when Twitter was “Twitter,” coaches wore suits instead of officially licensed pajamas, and teams made 34 percent of their tournament threes. Alas, that statistical gravity is now centered at 33 percent. Today’s variable but still tethered all-day, all-round, or all-bracket highs for accuracy won’t be as high as we (correctly!) remember them being in the Before Times. The lows will be lower.

Last year at this time I presented the 25 best games of NCAA men’s tournament offense in the KenPom era. Alas, that list is already outdated. This past weekend of 2025 tournament action brought us two new entries to add.

Here’s the updated version of what I have for the top 25 games of tournament offense ever. As usual, “best ever” is understood to encompass just the most recent 34 percent of tournaments as archived faithfully by my friend Ken.

Tough luck, old times! You should have tracked offensive boards and turnovers sooner and more frequently.

But before anyone asks: Villanova’s “Perfect Game” against Georgetown in 1985 comes in at 1.16 points per possession. Perfect shooting, yes, but turnovers were committed.

This is a very unofficial curation. Corrections and additions are welcome.

Still, it’s likely that four of the best seven tournament games on offense ever came from just two individual tournament runs. And one of those teams didn’t even reach the national title game. March Madness is beautiful, truly.

The men’s NCAA tournament field expanded to 64 teams in 1985 only after years of opposition. Then Villanova upset Georgetown in an iconic final and pretty much everyone loved the new format after all.

We call this the modern tournament era, which is perhaps a bit presumptuous. Even at this late date, there were more tournaments played before 1985 than have been contested since.

Still, “modern” makes descriptive sense. These brackets have shot clocks and three-point lines (starting in 1986 and 1987, respectively).

Expanding the field did away with byes, giving us a trusty measuring stick when teams accumulate tournament victories over the years. Yes, the NCAA muddied that up a bit by expanding past 64 teams starting in 2001, but we can adjust with a well-placed asterisk here and there.

UConn is moving up fast on the leaderboard for modern-era tournament victories. Winning two titles in the span of about 390 days vaulted the Huskies past Michigan State, Arizona, and Syracuse.

Winningest NCAA tournament teams, 1985-2024

                         Wins
1.  Duke                 105    
2.  North Carolina        98 
3.  Kansas                94
4.  Kentucky              84
5.  UConn                 67
6.  Michigan State        63
7.  Arizona               58
8.  Syracuse              57* 2018
9.  UCLA                  55* 2021
10. Michigan              51* 2016
11. Louisville            49
12. Florida               48
13. Villanova             47
14. Gonzaga               46
15. Purdue                40
16. Arkansas              38
17. Oklahoma              37
    Indiana               37* 2022
19. Wisconsin             36
20. Ohio State            35
    Maryland              35

* Round of 68 wins

One measurement of performance in the NCAA tournament is wins above or below what every other team with the same seed has done. The difference between expected wins and your actual victories is performance against seed expectations (PASE).

Back in the day, PASE was shaping up to be a handy item. Then the field expanded to 68 teams, and assigning praise and blame became a bit less tidy with a few extra results knocking around.

The proposal here is to ignore the round of 68 entirely, both its wins and its losses. Take Virginia’s loss to Colorado State in the round of 68 this year. Don’t worry, Cavaliers. Never mind, ACC. For PASE purposes, we’ll simply count as though the Hoos missed the tournament entirely. Which they kind of played like they did. The Rams, conversely, do count as a No. 10 seed that won zero games in the 2024 tournament.

Based on tournament results from 1985 through 2024, here are the values for expected wins by seed starting from the round of 64. If you greet that first Thursday morning with one of the following numbers still listed as a live fact next to your name, this is what we expect of you….

seed    expected Ws       seed    expected Ws
  1.       3.30            9.        0.62
  2.       2.33            10.       0.60           
  3.       1.84            11.       0.67          
  4.       1.56            12.       0.51       
  5.       1.15            13.       0.26
  6.       1.04            14.       0.15
  7.       0.90            15.       0.10
  8.       0.71            16.       0.01

Wins in and subsequent to round of 64 only